Attorneys for Hard Working Families ®

SERVING CLIENTS HARMED BY NEGLIGENCE

LET US FIGHT FOR YOU

Amazon Bestselling Author

Scott L. Frost, Co-Author of Amazon Bestseller “Flip the Script”

Learn More
MULTI-MILLION $ VERDICTS
We have a history of achieving verdicts worth several millions of dollars for our clients.
NO FEE UNLESS WE WIN
You will never have to pay any fees unless we recover money on your behalf.
COMPLEX CASES
We have experience winning complex cases that other attorneys won’t even take.

What Is the Difference Between Reckless Driving Vs. Negligence in Truck Crash Cases?

The last thing you want to hear after being smashed into by a semi-truck is excuses.

Between medical treatment, body shop estimates, and figuring out how to get around without a car, filing an insurance claim can feel like one thing too many. So it might seem beside the point to ask whether the truck driver who caused your crash was reckless or negligent. The result is the same: your life has been upended.

Is there a difference between reckless driving and negligence in a truck crash case?

Actually, there is, and that difference could have a direct impact on what you’re entitled to ask for as part of your compensation package. A skilled California truck accident attorney can help identify that distinction and support you through the entire claims process. Accidents with trucks can get complicated fast.

That’s why you need strong legal counsel to help you understand all your options and who to hold responsible.

Reckless Driving Versus Negligence

10,810. That is the number of vehicles involved in fatal and non-fatal crashes between cars and large trucks in California, according to the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA). Many of these crashes trace back to reckless driving or negligence. What is the difference between the two?

Think of negligence as a simple mistake or lapse in judgment, while recklessness is extreme indifference or a deliberate choice.

Examples of Negligence:

  • Momentary distraction like adjusting the radio
  • Failing to signal a lane change
  • Picking up a drink
  • Misjudging stopping distance in light rain
  • Rubbernecking

Examples of Recklessness:

  • Driving a commercial semi-truck while heavily intoxicated
  • Excessive speeding well over the limit in heavy traffic
  • Intentionally violating federal Hours of Service rules to drive while dangerously fatigued

Once you identify the conditions that contributed to your crash, you’ll be able to build up your claim.

How the Burden of Proof Works in Trucking Litigation

When you’re injured by a truck driver’s negligence or reckless driving, you carry the burden of proof. You and your attorney need to demonstrate the specifics of the negligence or reckless driving along with the link between that act and your accident. You also need to detail all the damages.

Because a truck accident claim is a civil complaint, you only have to prove it by a preponderance of the evidence, which means the reasons for the crash are more likely than not to have happened.

Here’s what might be part of your claim:

Regulatory violations: An investigation into the events leading to the crash could reveal that the driver or the trucking company violated safety regulations established by the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA), such as faulty equipment or violating service hours. That can shift the burden of proof or establish negligence per se, which requires the driver or company to prove an alternate cause.

Affirmative defenses: If the trucking company argues that you or a third party share blame under California’s pure comparative negligence rule, established by the state Supreme Court in 1975’s Li v. Yellow Cab Co., the burden shifts to the company to prove it.

Exclusive control of evidence: If a trucking company fails to preserve black box data, electronic logging device files, or maintenance records after they’ve been issued a preservation notice, courts may instruct a jury to infer those lost records could have proved negligence.

Impact of Driver Conduct on Compensatory and Punitive Damages

The issue of negligence or reckless driving can have a direct effect on the damages you can recover. In either scenario, you’re entitled to receive your full compensatory damages.

These include all losses attributed to your accident, such as medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering. Punitive damages are possible, but they are a separate matter and a much higher bar. Rather than compensating you for a specific loss, these damages punish the driver or trucking company to discourage similar conduct.

Why You Need a Specialized Attorney for Your Truck Crash Claim

There is a lot to unpack with any car accident, but that is especially true with a collision involving a commercial vehicle. State laws and detailed federal safety regulations govern the trucking industry. All of that can come into play, extending liability beyond the driver to the trucking company or other parties. These added complexities are why you need the support of an experienced California truck accident attorney.

If Frost Law Firm, PC, agrees to work with you on your claim, we’ll conduct a thorough investigation, including obtaining driver logs, electronic or “black box” data, dashcam and surveillance footage, police reports, eyewitness accounts, and evidence of safety violations.

We’ll also look into the trucking company’s actions such as negligent hiring or training, inadequate truck maintenance, unrealistic delivery schedules, or violations of federal Hours of Service requirements. We examine all the facts to determine what role negligence or reckless driving played in the accident.

If you were injured in a collision involving a commercial truck, you do not have to take on the trucking company and its insurer by yourself. Contact Frost Law Firm, PC, to schedule a free case evaluation.

Let’s find out together what should happen next.

 

 

 

We have a commitment to our veterans. Let us help.

Awards & Recognitions

AAJ Diplomate
Top One Percent